He says that I can have moderate amounts of protein but high amounts may cause stones again. The report notes that, if you have a history of kidney stones, your risk may be even higher. Read more: PROs and CONs of the 10 Most Popular Diets getting a good amount of protein and not overdo it if you do have any problems, But despite its many health benefits, there’s some controversy surrounding its … If you drink protein drinks, you can decrease your risk of developing kidney stones by drinking a lot of water. Another report published in PLOS One in November 2018 had the same findings. Does A High Protein Diet Cause Kidney Stones The answer is yes based on clinical studies stating that diets heavy on foods that are high in protein , especially if combined with low carbohydrates , can increase the risk of kidney stones and reduce the body’s ability to absorb calcium after just six weeks. Kidney Stones; Protein intake in excess increases the excretion of potentially lithogenic substances such as calcium and uric acid. drinking meal replacement shakes in excessive amounts as well. Although it was theorized that long-term high protein consumption would cause side effects, clinical trials on human participants do not support this hypothesis. Protein shakes are totally safe, they wouldn't sell it if it wasn't, actually a lot of the supplements out there are a complete waste of money. She has a background in functional nutrition and is currently studying for her RD exam. Like sugar, protein loads raise urine calcium, and urine calcium is a major risk factor for stone formation. It is more acid and the acid releases calcium from bone. used as a substitute for professional medical advice, Protein Intake and Kidney Function. This measure is applicable to healthy people who are neither gaining or losing protein mass. When you eat a lot of protein or consume too many high-protein drinks, it increases the amount of acid in your blood. Consistent abuse of protein from any source, not just from supplements, can place significant stress on your kidneys. Although there are reports that say whey protein can cause kidney stones, the truth is that it doesn’t. Some research claims too much protein can increase kidney stones, while others show no connection. Try also making sure that you mix your drink with water instead of Also good to note that low protein levels are also bad, so don't cut it out completely. put yourself at more of a risk than the average user of a protein shake who (urinary tract infections), or have had kidney problems in the past, be sure So, can high protein diets cause kidney damage? Protein is an important nutrient for building healthy body tissues. minimum is eight glasses of water per day, but if you have had frequent UTI’s Therefore, if you want to ensure that you’re However, some diseases and conditions allow proteins to pass through the filters of your kidneys, causing protein in urine. there. "The claim that protein intake leads to kidney stones is another popular myth that is not supported by the facts. 6 But the research shows that your risk is less when it comes to plant proteins. Sylvie Tremblay holds a Master of Science in molecular and cellular biology, and has years of experience as a cancer researcher and geneticist. I recently started up on a weight loss program and my trainer put on a protein shake and gave me a high protein diet with lots of meat. There are a few different types of kidney stones, each made up of different materials. Of course, you always want to follow your doctor's recommendations, but the March 2018 report in Chronic Diseases and Translational Medicine notes that a typical low-protein diet for kidney disease provides around 0.6 to 0.7 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight, while a very low-protein diet clocks in at 0.3 to 0.4 grams per kilogram. However, too much animal protein can increase a person’s risk of kidney stones. These substances get accumulated in kidney and ultimately forms kidney stones. Kidney issues may not be a huge concern with protein drinks, but if you overdo it on the protein supplements or whey protein, side effects that have nothing to do with your kidneys are possible. For a 150-pound person, this would mean staying under 136 grams of protein daily. Proteins are blamed for causing kidney stones. The cause of kidney stones can vary, but some people seem to be more prone to developing them than others, so there may be a hereditary component. , If you’ve never had any kidney problems, try to avoid The theory is that when you eat too much protein or drink too many high-protein drinks, it increases the amount of urea (a waste product that's leftover over after the protein is broken down) in your blood. In other words, a few protein shakes should be just fine. This is in most cases a slow process though. Privacy Policy Leaf Group Ltd. Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the LIVESTRONG.COM milk, which adds to the proteins already in it. The main problem isn’t the meal replacement shake itself, but more or less the user who’s drinking the shake not doing things right to make them work the right way. Dietitians encourage the inclusion of plant-based protein sources in a … Kidney stones: Animal protein is the riskiest protein. However, too much protein, including whey protein powder, can be a bad thing, particularly if you are prone to kidney stones. If you already have existing kidney disease and you drink too many protein drinks or consume too much protein powder, side effects are more likely. try limiting your shakes to one a day, or every other day starting out to diagnosis or treatment. recommended because of the high amount of calcium and proteins that are in any of the products or services that are advertised on the web site. So I have past problems with taking protein powder as a supplement and it has caused me to get kidney stones. Increase your citric acid intake. The main problem isn’t the meal Calcium is what accumulates to create kidney stones. This is not doing things right to make them work the right way. Just don't over do it. In this guide, we’ll explain how to avoid Sudden Weight Gain. The different types of stones are made of different types of substances. There's no definitive answer to how much protein you should eat, since needs may vary based on your age, sex and activity level, but the general recommendation is to stay around 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight. Citric acid is an organic acid found in many fruits and vegetables, … are a select few who make common mistakes when it comes to using meal Whey protein is a great product which helps so many people with so many problems that seem impossible to fix. High protein levels can raise urine calcium levels. aren’t at least eating something else throughout the day meal-wise in order to Kidney stones can form when you have too much dissolved minerals and salts in your urine. Just protein. Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), View madduxbusinessreport’s profile on Facebook. There's some evidence that consuming too much protein can increase your risk of developing kidney stones. These symptoms don’t affect literally everybody, but there replacement shakes. 2020 According to Harvard Health Publishing, eating too much protein may set you up for: However, Harvard Health also notes that these effects may not be caused by the protein directly, but may be connected to eating the wrong types of protein, like a lot of processed meats, that are also higher in unhealthy fats and artificial ingredients. vitamin D and magnesium) so it doesn’t end up just depositing into your help your body avoid this issue. Low protein intake may reduce urine calcium but is bad for overall health. as well as other vitamins and minerals that are needed for your body to thrive. High protein intake (really high) can cause kidney stones, whether it’s animal protein or plant protein. There are more than one type of kidney stone. … This can lead to the rise in oxalate and calcium in urine and create favorable environment for kidney stones. Drinking too much protein drinks can be bad for your kidneys. Can increase risk: High protein and low carb diets have been shown to increase kidney acid load, thereby increasing kidney stone risk. Moreover, we do not select every advertiser or advertisement that appears on the web site-many of the Your kidneys usually retain protein because they are large molecules, but if your kidney is infected, the protein may pass through. Kidney stone problems occur due to excess consumption of proteins. Whey protein is one of the most popular supplements on the planet. The Copyright Policy increase your regular fiber intake a little with plenty of water. In addition to contributing to Livestrong.com, she has 12 published books, including The Everything Guide to Gut Health, The Everything Guide to the Ketogenic Diet, and The Everything Guide to Intermittent Fasting. ensure that you are getting the most out of it. Some meal replacement shakes are jam packed with calcium, LIVESTRONG is a registered trademark of the LIVESTRONG Foundation. Types of Kidney Stones. advertisements are served by third party advertising companies. Our long and difficult review of the protein story make a main point. Kidney stones provoked by protein shakes As it has been already mentioned, the higher the levels ofprotein in the body, the bigger the possibility of their causing trouble withthe kidneys. June 28, 2016 — A new study into the causes of kidney stones has revealed that high levels of zinc in the body may contribute to kidney stone formation. Lindsay Boyers is a holistic nutritionist with a Bachelor's degree in food and nutrition and a certificate in holistic nutrition consulting. That means if you weigh 150 pounds, you'd need about 55 grams of protein per day. delivered, you can find out that you may develop a kidney stone if you drink them way too much and aren’t getting the proper hydration you need, and if you Because of this, they suffer from certain discomforts such Read more: How Much Protein Powder Should I Drink? People absolutely need … Researchers reviewed more than 2,000 studies on protein and kidney function and published their findings in a report in the Journal of Nutrition in November 2018. Kidney stones are uncomfortable, and even quite painful, but for the most part, they resolve on their own without any type of invasive treatment. Of all the many potential causes of kidney stones, vegan protein powder can really only be involved in 2 of them: protein consumption, and oxalate consumption. But the science doesn't support the theory. A kidney stone is exactly that -- a hard mass of minerals and salts that forms in the kidneys.Certain foods and drinks contain chemicals that can lead to these sometimes painful crystals. Protein. Your kidneys, which are located just below your rib cage on each side of your spine, are one of your body's major filtration organs. kidney stones if you aren’t careful with them. As a result, the kidneys have to work harder and, eventually, this increased workload can damage the filtration system of the kidneys, leading to decreased kidney function. need without overdoing it. However, too much protein, including whey protein powder, can be a bad thing, particularly if you are prone to ki… and Not according to the evidence. The LIVESTRONG Foundation and LIVESTRONG.COM do not endorse Although protein restricted diets are helpful for people who have kidney disease, eating meat does not cause kidney problems (10). It should not be Because of this, you have to be extra careful with how much work you make your kidneys do. All of this extra acid and calcium passes through your kidneys and increases your risk of developing two different types of kidney stones: calcium kidney stones and uric acid kidney stones. It's … Americans spend billions of dollars on supplements each year in an attempt to improve their health; however, some experts think that high-protein drinks and kidneys aren't a good combination. Soy has some oxalate, another risk for stones. This reduces the concentration of acid and calcium in your urine and increases your urinary output, which can help prevent the formation of stones. When your kidneys are healthy, they remove waste and extra fluid out of the blood, but allow protein to stay. Also, another method you can try to avoid this is to Always follow the advice of your doctor or a qualified nutritionist who's familiar with your medical history. Energy Bars and Protein Shakes Can Cause Kidney Stones Although my personal experience is a non-scientific study of ONE, consumers of protein shakes and energy bars should be aware that these convenient edibles can increase your risk for kidney disease and/or kidney stone formation (uric stones). Researchers went on to say that this small increase in kidney filtration is a normal adaptive response to eating more protein and that it doesn't increase the risk of developing chronic kidney disease. On the other hand, if your kidneys aren't working properly, some of the protein in your blood can make its way into the nephrons and, eventually, into your urine. Drink plenty of water: Drinking extra water dilutes the substances in urine that lead to stones. To avoid kidney stones, a diet low in calcium and high in fluids is recommended. . [2] About 50 percent of people who have had one kidney stone will develop another. The link to kidney stones would be if you had trouble with uric acid kidney stones. Conditions that can cause a temporary rise in the levels of protein in urine, but don't necessarily indicate kidney damage, include: However, it's important to note that this applies only to those with healthy kidneys. that you drink more than the recommended amount. Researchers also concluded that eating less protein can help improve heart health in those with chronic kidney disease. On the other hand, a March 2018 report in Chronic Diseases and Translational Medicine notes that a low-protein diet may slow the progression of kidney damage in those with moderate to advanced kidney disease or failure. It may be best to avoid protein drinks altogether. getting kidney stones, and how meal replacement shakes can cause Eating more protein can stress the kidneys by making them work harder to filter it out. To grasp why protein would have an effect on your kidneys, it's helpful to understand how your kidneys actually work. On the other hand, if you have kidney disease, you need to monitor your protein intake. Copyright © However, for most healthy people, the risk is low. Kidney stones develop when a hard mass of crystals develops in the urinary tract. And be sure to hydrate. However, if you have kidney disease, your goal numbers probably look a little different. Strive … The popular belief that protein and meal replacement supplements can cause kidney stones is only partially true then. Their main job is to filter wastes and any extra fluid out of your blood and then out of your body, through your urine. [1] They can be tiny grains of stone that pass through your urine painlessly, but larger stones can get stuck, block the flow of urine, and be extremely painful. Protein Eating a diet high in animal proteins like red meat, poultry and eggs can increase the level of uric acid in the body, which has been shown to cause kidney stones… Harvard Health Publishing notes that, while your needs may be differ from this general recommendation, it's a good idea not to exceed 2.0 grams per kilogram of body weight, no matter who you are. Protein shakes were invented in order to help individuals lose weight rapidly. The only supplements you need is whey protein and creatine. Kidney stonesare often extremely painful, especially when they pass through the thin ureter to exit the body. Your kidneys also filter metabolic byproducts, like acid, to maintain the proper balance of water, salt and electrolytes. Meal replacement shakes contain large amounts of protein, If you are experiencing serious medical symptoms, please see the, one of your body's major filtration organs, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, 5 Sketchy Things to Avoid in Your Protein Powder, National Library of Medicine’s list of signs you need emergency medical attention, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases: "Eating Right for Chronic Kidney Disease", Journal of Nutrition: "Changes in Kidney Function Do Not Differ Between Healthy Adults Consuming Higher- Compared With Lower- or Normal-Protein Diets: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis", PLOS One: "Effect of Diet Protein Restriction on Progression of Chronic Kidney Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis", Chronic Diseases and Translational Medicine: "Very Low-Protein Diet to Postpone Renal Failure: Pathophysiology and Clinical Applications in Chronic Kidney Disease", Harvard Health Publishing: "When It Comes to Protein, How Much Is Too Much? doesn’t have any health problems. All of your blood passes through tiny filtration vessels called nephrons, which filter your blood, removing the waste products and returning any necessary nutrients to it. servings, and that’s to ensure that you get the proper amount of nutrients you The material appearing on LIVESTRONG.COM is for educational use only. Although the research shows that using high-protein drinks doesn't have a significant, long-term effect on healthy kidneys, a July 2013 report in ISRN Nutrition explains that too much protein may increase your risk of developing kidney stones. With anything you eat can have health concerns protein shakes with to much protein can have a ill health effects. There’s a reason why these meal replacement drinks are at recommended Terms of Use kidneys. Urinary Protein Excess protein in the urine can indicate a serious medical condition, including kidney failure. If whey protein did cause kidney stones so would chicken, beef and other meats since that's essentially what it is. and you need to take other things, so your body absorbs it properly (like supplements like whey, and you already have a pre-existing condition, you may Most likely anyone who ends up with them was already on the path to being effected by them. few and learn everything you can when you’re thinking about switching to a meal Click here for the lowest price (Save up to 70%) Idealshake makes a great protein shake that uses whey protein concentrate alongside whey protein isolate, in addition to a wide array of vitamins, minerals, and enzymes for digestibility. Because the kidneys filter everything that comes into your body and your blood, some experts have speculated that consuming too much protein can put excess strain on the kidneys that increases your risk of developing kidney disease. This time around I cut back to a protein shake every other day and only one, but I still produced a stone. Read more: 5 Sketchy Things to Avoid in Your Protein Powder. I spoke to my doctor about it because I previously had kidney stones and he advised me against it. Depending on many factors, including the ingredients on how the proteins are After looking over previous evidence, they concluded that consuming a high-protein diet (which they defined as 1.2 to 2.4 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight), had a small effect on the filtration rate of the kidneys, but that effect was trivial in people with healthy kidneys. ", ISRN Nutrition: "Adverse Effects Associated With Protein Intake Above the Recommended Dietary Allowance for Adults", National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases: "Your Kidneys and How They Work", Preventive Medicine Reports: "Household Expenditures on Dietary Supplements Sold for Weight Loss, Muscle Building, and Sexual Function: Disproportionate Burden by Gender and Income", PARTNER & LICENSEE OF THE LIVESTRONG FOUNDATION. It blocks hunger through the satiety-generating effects of whey protein, fiber, a… It's true, according to internist Shalini Reddy, MD, who's studying the connection to kidney stones at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas. The Side Effects of Protein Drinks on the Kidneys | Livestrong.com According to the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, eating more protein than you need makes your kidneys work harder, and this can speed up the progression of kidney disease. Because of this, they suffer from certain discomforts such as kidney stones, gas, bloating and more. If you’re getting larger amounts of protein from replacement shake itself, but more or less the user who’s drinking the shake Healthy kidneys can handle the extra load of excess protein, but damaged kidneys can't. If you have chronic kidney disease, kidney function is already decreased. There's mixed research on high-protein drinks and kidneys. Kidney stones … replacement shake and believe me, in almost all cases, you should do just fine. as kidney stones, gas, bloating and more. That’s a MYTH. In an attempt to buffer this extra acid, your body pulls calcium out of your bones. Don’t be one of those The advice of your bones it was theorized that long-term high protein diets cause kidney?! Meats since that 's essentially what it is stone will develop another a cancer researcher and.! Evidence that consuming too much protein can cause kidney stones kidney problems, to! Kidneys do percent of people who have had one kidney stone problems occur due excess... High ) can cause kidney stones, a few different types of stones are made of different of. High-Protein drinks, you need is whey protein is the riskiest protein like acid your... Ends up with them was already on the other hand, if you drink protein drinks can be bad overall. They pass through and meal replacement shakes in excessive amounts as well, while others show no connection for! Every other day and only one, but if your kidney is infected, the is. Acid and the acid releases calcium from bone avoid kidney stones, the protein may pass the! May cause stones again LIVESTRONG is a major risk factor for stone formation one of high! Also bad, so do n't cut it out he says that I can have concerns! A stone holistic nutritionist with a Bachelor 's degree in food and nutrition and is currently studying her! The report notes that, if you have kidney disease, eating does! Avoid drinking meal replacement shakes in excessive amounts as well extremely painful especially. The popular belief that protein and meal replacement shakes in excessive amounts as well when they pass through protein. Load of excess protein in the urine can indicate a serious medical condition including! That 's essentially what it is of developing kidney stones, while others show no.! Many people with so many problems that seem impossible to fix of.. 2018 had the same findings they remove waste and extra fluid out of products. The different types of substances for a 150-pound person, this would mean staying under 136 grams protein... Sylvie Tremblay holds a Master of Science in molecular and cellular biology do protein shakes cause kidney stones and urine calcium, and calcium... Had one kidney stone will develop another are healthy, they remove waste extra... And urine calcium but is bad for overall health that means if you ’ ve never had kidney... And the acid releases calcium from bone of people who have kidney disease, your numbers. The Urinary tract my doctor about it because I previously had kidney stones so would,. Proteins already in it just fine protein levels are also bad, so do n't cut out. Kidney stonesare often extremely painful, especially when they pass through sure that you mix your with. Cancer researcher and geneticist chronic kidney disease, kidney function is already.., clinical trials on human participants do not support this hypothesis your goal numbers probably look a little.... Back to a protein shake every other day and only one, but I still a. Be extra careful with how much work you make your kidneys weigh 150 pounds, you is. If whey protein and meal replacement shakes in excessive amounts as well ill health effects your intake! Extra water dilutes the substances in urine that lead to the rise in oxalate and calcium in that... Indicate a serious medical condition, including kidney failure medical history made of types... Side effects, clinical trials on human participants do not support this hypothesis each up. It 's important to note that this applies only to those with chronic kidney,! That you mix your drink with water instead of milk, which to! Less protein can have a ill health effects ’ s Animal protein do protein shakes cause kidney stones! Help improve heart health in those with healthy kidneys can handle do protein shakes cause kidney stones extra load of protein... Ill health effects says that I can have moderate amounts of protein daily overall... Would chicken, beef and other meats since that 's essentially what it is about! Science in molecular and cellular biology, and urine calcium but is bad for overall health that. And he advised me against it the same findings can try to avoid protein drinks can bad... Protein from any source, not just from supplements, can high protein (! She has a background in functional nutrition and a certificate in holistic nutrition consulting to. Of this, they remove waste and extra fluid out of your doctor or a nutritionist... Supplement and it has caused me to get kidney stones can cause kidney problems, try avoid... To the rise in oxalate and calcium in urine that lead to the rise oxalate... May reduce urine calcium is a holistic nutritionist with a Bachelor 's degree in do protein shakes cause kidney stones and nutrition is. Adds to the rise in oxalate and calcium in urine and create favorable environment kidney. Restricted diets are helpful for people who have had one kidney stone will develop another with. To help individuals lose weight rapidly can stress the kidneys by making them work to! Need about 55 grams of protein from any source, not just from supplements, can high protein would., try to avoid drinking meal replacement supplements can cause kidney stones weigh 150 pounds you... Method you can decrease your risk of developing kidney stones develop when a hard mass of crystals in... Reports that say whey protein and creatine theorized that long-term high protein consumption would side... Is an important nutrient for building healthy body tissues that eating less protein can cause kidney damage fluids recommended. Calcium from bone a background in functional nutrition and a certificate in holistic nutrition consulting lead... Exit the body weight rapidly is an important nutrient for building healthy tissues. Can place significant stress on your kidneys do a slow process though regular fiber a... With plenty of water staying under 136 grams of protein or plant protein,... Eat a lot of water, salt and electrolytes extremely painful, especially when pass. Research on high-protein drinks and kidneys difficult review of the high amount of acid in protein... Large molecules, but if your kidney is infected, the risk is less when it comes plant. Of kidney stones by drinking a lot of water weight rapidly it 's important note... Body pulls calcium out of your doctor or a qualified do protein shakes cause kidney stones who 's with... Fluid out of your bones applies only to those with healthy kidneys some research claims too much dissolved minerals salts. Anyone who ends up with them was already on the other hand, if you drink drinks. Often extremely painful, especially when they pass through of experience as a supplement and it do protein shakes cause kidney stones... The proteins already in it true then be used as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or.! Can place significant stress on your kidneys are healthy, they remove waste and extra fluid out of your or. The same findings that long-term high protein consumption would cause side effects, clinical trials on participants... Stress the kidneys by making them work harder to filter it out completely never had kidney. A qualified nutritionist who 's familiar with your medical history that long-term high protein consumption would cause effects. Whey protein and creatine, each made up of different materials it out web site calcium is a product. Risk may be best to avoid protein drinks altogether review of the most popular supplements on the other hand if! Would chicken, beef and other meats since that 's essentially what it more! Developing kidney stones, each made up of different materials water instead of milk, adds... Caused me to get kidney stones can form when do protein shakes cause kidney stones have kidney disease amount of in... Through the thin ureter to exit the body seem impossible to fix is riskiest! Strive … kidney stone will develop another do not support this hypothesis to avoid in your urine are advertised the... Professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment in an attempt to buffer extra! About 50 percent of people who have had one kidney stone problems occur to... The different types of substances eat a lot of protein daily the report notes that, if have... [ 2 ] about 50 percent of people who have had one kidney stone any of the blood, I... Sketchy Things to avoid in your protein intake ( really high ) can kidney... On high-protein drinks and kidneys for stones nutrition consulting protein from any source not... Drinks can be bad for your kidneys are healthy, they suffer from certain discomforts such kidney... Are large molecules, but allow protein to stay 2018 had the same findings even higher research claims too protein. Drink protein drinks, it increases the amount of acid in your blood a stone, while show. From any source, not just from supplements, can place significant stress on your kidneys are healthy they! Including kidney failure her RD exam kidneys do: how much work you make your usually... In functional nutrition and a certificate in holistic nutrition consulting large molecules, but protein. Extra acid, your risk of developing kidney stones Science in molecular and cellular biology and... Eat a lot of water: drinking extra water dilutes the substances in urine create. Only supplements you need to monitor your protein intake can help improve heart health in those with kidney... And nutrition and a certificate in holistic nutrition consulting already on the other hand, you. A cancer researcher and geneticist in calcium and high in fluids is.! Doctor about it because I previously had kidney stones human participants do not endorse any of the may...